What is a startup recruiter?

Max Kolysh

CEO @ Dover

August 13, 2024

4 min

During the early stages of your startup, you and the founding team likely tackled all of the recruiting. But at some point, a startup needs a recruiting process handled by a dedicated recruiter. First Round Review says that the ideal time to bring a recruiter on board is when your startup reaches around 15 to 30 employees. This is when things are going to continue to rapidly grow, and the founding team isn’t going to have the time that is needed to bring on quality hires.

But what is a startup recruiter and how do you hire the right one for your company? In short, you should view a startup recruiter as a strategic partner and extension of your founding team, rather than simply headhunters who source as many candidates as possible. Startup recruiters will represent your company and will be critical going forward as they bring in hires that grow your company and push it forward. 

So, whether you’re going in-house or hiring an external recruiter, it’s important to make the right choice. In this guide, we’ll talk about how startup recruitment works, the benefits of recruiters, hiring tips, and more. Let’s dive in.

During the early stages of your startup, you and the founding team likely tackled all of the recruiting. But at some point, a startup needs a recruiting process handled by a dedicated recruiter. First Round Review says that the ideal time to bring a recruiter on board is when your startup reaches around 15 to 30 employees. This is when things are going to continue to rapidly grow, and the founding team isn’t going to have the time that is needed to bring on quality hires.

But what is a startup recruiter and how do you hire the right one for your company? In short, you should view a startup recruiter as a strategic partner and extension of your founding team, rather than simply headhunters who source as many candidates as possible. Startup recruiters will represent your company and will be critical going forward as they bring in hires that grow your company and push it forward. 

So, whether you’re going in-house or hiring an external recruiter, it’s important to make the right choice. In this guide, we’ll talk about how startup recruitment works, the benefits of recruiters, hiring tips, and more. Let’s dive in.

During the early stages of your startup, you and the founding team likely tackled all of the recruiting. But at some point, a startup needs a recruiting process handled by a dedicated recruiter. First Round Review says that the ideal time to bring a recruiter on board is when your startup reaches around 15 to 30 employees. This is when things are going to continue to rapidly grow, and the founding team isn’t going to have the time that is needed to bring on quality hires.

But what is a startup recruiter and how do you hire the right one for your company? In short, you should view a startup recruiter as a strategic partner and extension of your founding team, rather than simply headhunters who source as many candidates as possible. Startup recruiters will represent your company and will be critical going forward as they bring in hires that grow your company and push it forward. 

So, whether you’re going in-house or hiring an external recruiter, it’s important to make the right choice. In this guide, we’ll talk about how startup recruitment works, the benefits of recruiters, hiring tips, and more. Let’s dive in.

How startup recruitment works

How startup recruitment works

Startup recruitment is a multi-stage process, and there’s usually a particular emphasis on cultural fit. Startup teams need to be lean, versatile, and tight-knit so the company can grow and find success during the crucial early stages. Also getting people on board with the mission and vision of the company from the beginning is key to achieving long-term goals and actually reaching the mission. With that in mind, the startup recruitment process usually includes the following steps:


  • Preparation - Startups need to take the time to prepare and define the roles they need and the responsibilities those roles are going to take on. They need to outline the skills, experience, and other things a new hire needs to have. Preparation also means getting read for the actual hiring process by determining who is handling interviews, questions to ask, and other pertinent details.

  • Crafting the job description - A job description needs to be succinct and appealing to top talent. This is an important stage of the recruiting process, because a good job description will help you get as many qualified applicants as possible while minimizing applications from unqualified candidates.

  • Sourcing candidates - Sourcing candidates can be a difficult and time-consuming process without the right tools and strategies in place. Casting a wide net by using various channels like job boards, social media, and referrals can help you find a diverse, qualified batch of candidates to interview.

  • Screening resumes and applications - Once you have applications, you can start screening them and finding your top choices that you want to interview. This can also take a long time without software tools like an applicant tracking system or a recruiter helping you out.

  • Interviewing candidates - The multi-stage interview process typically involves screening calls, interviews with various stakeholders, technical interviews if necessary, and anything else you need to assess the qualifications, experience, and cultural fit of the top candidates. 

  • Making an offer and negotiating - Finally, you present an offer to your chosen candidate and negotiate if necessary.

  • Onboarding - The process doesn’t end after the candidate accepts an offer. New hires should be properly onboarding so you can set them up for success and ensure their integration into the company goes as smoothly as possible. 

What are the benefits of hiring a recruiter?

What are the benefits of hiring a recruiter?

Nearly all of the above steps for recruitment are something that a recruiter can help with, and this is especially useful for startups that may not have the resources or expertise to handle the difficult startup recruitment process. Overall, some of the biggest benefits of hiring a recruiter include:


  • Save time - Recruiters can save you time in a lot of ways. For one, they streamline the hiring process so you don’t spend as much time sourcing candidates and screening them. But, they also help make great hires, which means less turnover and less time wasted on hires that end up leaving quickly.

  • Access to expertise - A recruiter gives you instant access to hiring expertise and knowledge your team might not have. They come equipped with the skills needed to attract top talent and screen applicants quickly.

  • Reach more candidates - Recruiters have extensive networks and knowledge of multiple sourcing channels, helping you reach a broader talent pool of candidates.

  • Hire quality candidates - Of course, one of the top benefits of using a recruiter is their ability to hire quality candidates. Finding top talent isn’t easy, but the right recruiter can make it much easier.

  • Market knowledge - Recruiters have insight into what candidates are looking for in your industry. This includes salary trends, helping you to make more competitive and appealing offers.

Startup recruiting vs. traditional recruiting

Startup recruiting vs. traditional recruiting

While both startup and traditional or corporate recruiting aim to find the best talent, the processes and priorities can be quite different. Some of the biggest differences between startup recruiting and traditional recruiting include:

Pace and Flexibility - Startups are rapidly growing and changing, so the recruitment process needs to be adaptable and agile to keep pace. Corporate recruiting tends to be more structured and slow-paced, since they have a large bench of employees to keep things going as they wait for a role to be filled.

Cultural Fit - In startups, cultural fit is a top priority. Early hires impact company culture and will shape the startup going forward. Corporations are big enough that new hires won’t change how things work, and technical skills and experience may be weighed more heavily compared to cultural fit.

Diversity of Roles - Startup recruiters look for adaptable generalists who can wear multiple hats rather than candidates with hyper-specific expertise. Corporations can afford to look for more niche expertise, whereas startups need their employees to be as flexible as possible.

Budget - Startups may have limited budgets for salaries and benefits, requiring creative negotiation and value proposition by recruiters.

How to hire a recruiter specializing in startups

If you’ve decided a recruiter is right for your startup, the next step is hiring one. To hire a recruiter specializing in startups, you can follow these steps:

  • Identify Your Needs - Determine whether you need an in-house recruiter or an external recruiter based on your hiring volume and budget. Both have their pros and cons.

  • Look for Relevant Experience - Make sure you choose a recruiter that has experience working in startups, as they’ll have a better understanding of the challenges that come with startup hiring.

  • Check References - Don’t hesitate to vet your recruiter and look at references and their track record. You don’t have to overemphasize stats and metrics, but it’s good to see some solid recommendations from other startups.

  • Hire for Cultural Fit - Your recruiter should align with your culture and values. Even with external recruiters, you should view them as an extension of your team and the first impression candidates will get from your company.

  • Discuss Process - Vetting your recruiter also means asking about their process. Ask how they source candidates, their screening process, and other relevant questions to understand how they work and if that aligns with your company’s hiring processes.

  • Set Clear Expectations - Finally, talk about timelines and set clear expectations. A good recruiter should be able to outline what they can do in three months, six months, etc. 

Hiring tips for founders

Finally, here are some general tips for to help you make great hires for your startup:

Prioritize Cultural Fit and Flexibility - As mentioned, you want to look for adaptable generalists who can wear a lot of hats and also fit into your startup’s culture. Technical skills are necessary for some positions, but adaptability, communication, and problem-solving will also be crucial soft skills for startup hires. 

Be Transparent - Make sure new hires have a clear picture of your startup from the beginning. Be transparent about your vision, culture, and the challenges you’re bringing them on to help tackle.

Offer Competitive Packages - While you may not match corporate salaries, consider offering equity, flexible working conditions, and opportunities for growth.

Leverage Technology and Other Resources - Use applicant tracking systems (ATS) and other tools to streamline the recruitment process and keep track of candidates. External recruiters are also great resources if you can find the right fit.

Speed and Efficiency - The best candidates are often in high demand. Streamline your interview and decision-making process to avoid losing top talent to competitors.

If you want to make more great hires, then a recruiter can make a big difference. Dover is here to help.

Work with one of Dover’s hiring experts!

Let Dover help you get the specialization and expertise of a startup recruiter at a fraction of the cost. Our Recruiting Partners are full-cycle recruiters that work with you and within your hiring process to fill your open roles with quality hires. Instead of locking you into long term commitments at expensive rates, our Recruiting Partners are priced for startups and work on an hourly basis, so you can use them as little or as often as you need.

This flexibility doesn’t mean you have to compromise on quality. Our Recruiting Partners will give you the same level of attention and skill as an in-house recruiter, representing your brand and bringing knowledge and enthusiasm to the table that makes top talent want to join your company. From sourcing to screening to handling hiring logistics, our Recruiting Partners make the hiring process easy. Ready to work with an expert recruiter? Find your recruiter with Dover today.

Subscribe to our blog

Table of contents

How startup recruitment works

What are the benefits of hiring a recruiter?

Startup recruiting vs. traditional recruiting

Kickstart recruiting with Dover's free ATS

Meet our Recruting Partners

Learn more