Should you Ditch Notion for a Real ATS?

Max Kolysh

CEO @ Dover

July 10, 2024

4 min

Notion Careers Page
Notion Careers Page
Notion Careers Page

When it comes to hiring, many startups turn to familiar tools like Notion, Google Sheets, or Airtable to manage their candidates. While these tools are great for basic organization, they quickly fall short once you start scaling your hiring efforts even a little bit. That's where a dedicated Applicant Tracking System (ATS) like Dover comes in.

The reason to use Notion as your ATS is just to get a basic careers page and application form up quickly. Other ATS's tend to be heavyweight and expensive, whereas Dover's ATS is 100% free and takes <15 minutes to set up — so the tradeoff of setting it up is worth it!

Here are the three biggest reasons to use Dover over Notion as your ATS:

When it comes to hiring, many startups turn to familiar tools like Notion, Google Sheets, or Airtable to manage their candidates. While these tools are great for basic organization, they quickly fall short once you start scaling your hiring efforts even a little bit. That's where a dedicated Applicant Tracking System (ATS) like Dover comes in.

The reason to use Notion as your ATS is just to get a basic careers page and application form up quickly. Other ATS's tend to be heavyweight and expensive, whereas Dover's ATS is 100% free and takes <15 minutes to set up — so the tradeoff of setting it up is worth it!

Here are the three biggest reasons to use Dover over Notion as your ATS:

#1: One-Click Job Board Postings

#1: One-Click Job Board Postings

With an ATS, you can post your job openings to multiple popular job boards with just one click. Candidates can then apply using a standardized application form, and their information is automatically imported into your ATS. No more cluttered inboxes or manual data entry.

#2: Application Review and Ranking

#2: Application Review and Ranking

Dover lets you set up search criteria to analyze and rank candidates based on their qualifications and fit for the role. This means you can quickly identify the best applicants without spending hours reviewing every single resume.

#3: Everything stays organized automatically

#3: Everything stays organized automatically

Once you start receiving a high volume of applications, an ATS helps keep everything organized. Email communications and calendar events are automatically synced to each candidate's profile, and you can easily bulk reject or advance candidates through your hiring process.

Other Benefits of using a Proper ATS

There are tons of other reasons you'll thank yourself for setting up a proper ATS like Dover from the get-go:

  • Automated interview scheduling and reminder emails for candidates

  • Customizable careers page with minimal setup

  • Collaborative hiring with team member access and notes

  • Detailed analytics and reporting on your hiring pipeline

  • Compliance handled for you

  • It takes <15 minutes to set up

  • It's free!

When Notion Might Be a Better Fit

While an ATS is the clear choice for most growing startups, there are a few scenarios where Notion or a similar tool might suffice:

  • If you are exclusively hiring through referrals, and you don't want to do any sourcing or receive any applicants (e.g. for your 1st employee)

  • If you prefer an ad-hoc interview process for every candidate you interview (some founders believe this to be better, but it's more likely to make your company look disorganized)

As a founder, your time is precious. By investing in a purpose-built ATS like Dover, you can automate and optimize your hiring process, freeing up your time to focus on growing your business. While tools like Notion and Google Sheets may seem like an easy solution, they simply can't provide the same level of functionality and efficiency as a dedicated ATS. Make the switch today and see the difference for yourself.

Subscribe to our blog

Table of contents

#1: One-Click Job Board Postings

#2: Application Review and Ranking

#3: Everything stays organized automatically

Other Benefits of using a Proper ATS

Other Benefits of using a Proper ATS

When Notion Might Be a Better Fit

When Notion Might Be a Better Fit

Kickstart recruiting with Dover's free ATS

Meet our Recruting Partners

Learn more